TOOL - Lateralus 25th Anniversary Analysis and Review
I'm a few months late, but I have a good excuse, promise. You'll find out in very soon! Let's discuss this album now. Maybe it was destined to be, but TOOL became one of my favorite bands growing up and remain to this day one of my all-time favorite artists. Their music actually called out to me unlike any other music some 20-something years ago. Allow me to explain.
Upon hearing their title track’s soft, opening guitar melody for the first time in my early teenage years, a meditative, almost religious-like refrain, at an undetermined time and place, the knowledge of who it was was lost to me, because as soon as it had come, it was gone, and I didn’t have the clarity to find out who I had heard. But the melody of Lateralus continued to whisper to me in many quiet moments for several years after, without me knowing who or what was replaying in my head. It felt like a lullaby or a comforting mantra that gave me this sense of peace that cut through all of the noise and the pain and the inner struggles I had growing up.
It wasn’t until several years later on a fateful day a short time after moving with my family to Connecticut that I heard the sound again, playing on a neighbors computer. “What is that song?!”, I could hear myself thinking. My eyes fixed upon the computer screen and on the dark, ambiguous album cover (the original one before streaming) and the title underneath it: Tool - Lateralus. At that moment, I had one of my great musical awakenings.
Fast forward more than two decades later and I’m writing a lot about music and classic albums that are beloved to many. I started this Masterpiece Crate series in 2019 and took some long breaks in between. I actually wrote about TOOL’s long-awaited 5th LP, Fear Inoculum, released that same year, which is number 3 in this series. It couldn’t be more perfect that the 25th anniversary of Lateralus, which is my next Masterpiece Crate analysis and review, slots in at number 8, a number with great significance. If you don’t know yet, read on, fellow Drifter…
Click or tap on any of the Table of Contents to jump to a particular section
Lateralus Ltd. Edition Vinyl Picture Disc
Introduction
TOOL is one of those rare acts that have remained important all throughout their 36 year career. All four of its members, Maynard James Keenan, Adam Jones, Danny Carey, and Justin Chancellor, are all masters of their craft in their own ways, including the visual artist behind their artwork, Alex Grey, who had sex with a corpse (I'm not even joking, look it up yourself so now you also live with this horrible knowledge, Spoiler alert: She was missing the top half of her head). It’s no wonder that when they get together and meld into one another, they create a body of work that is transcendent and music albums that will undoubtedly remain timeless classics. I know those words get thrown around often with fans of beloved artists, but it couldn’t be closer to the truth with TOOL.
Lateralus is their magnum opus. Unlike their ultra-refined Fear Inoculum, which gave me so many serotonin spikes due to its long awaited release that I quickly declared it a masterpiece, Lateralus is an all-encompassing work of art that really has no equal. Through all of its 13 (numerology) tracks, there is always something fruitful to be gained. So without any further explanation, let’s go song by song and discuss its importance.
The Grudge
The first song of the album doesn't hold back. It has a quiet industrial whirring that sounds like a machine that's starting up, shortly followed by the sudden, bludgeoning guitar riffs and drumming of Jones, Chancellor, and Carrey. To me, this quiet but quick to blow-your-ears-off opening sequence reminds me a lot of In The Flesh, the opening song off Pink Floyd's The Wall, with its cute little woodwind and outro of their last track, Outside the Wall, that is unexpectedly blindsided mid-note by a deafening chord progression. Both of these albums are equally epic and thematically rich, but Lateralus turns the heaviness that '70s rock and roll had to offer and turns it up to 11.
Clutch it like a cornerstone, otherwise it all comes down
Justify denials and grip 'em to the lonesome end
Clutch it like a cornerstone, otherwise it all comes down
Terrified of being wrong, ultimatum prison cell
Saturn ascends
Choose one or ten
Hang on or be humbled again
Humbled again
First discovering TOOL in high school, and learning of the Saturn Death Cult got me wondering if this song had any significance. Given their cryptic compositions, I wouldn’t put it past them to include something so ominous, since the guys admit to being fascinated by and thereby adding numerology, symbols, and esoteric influences in their music. This is an alleged elite cult that worships Saturn, hence the Saturn ascends, and who desire to control all the affairs of our physical world, hence the opening lyrics of being “desperate to control all and everything.”
This Saturn Death Cult also makes me think of Stanely Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey, when Kubrick switched the planet that the astronauts were originally traveling to in the book, Jupiter, to Saturn. Why did he choose to switch to this planet from Jupiter? Was it to send a message or reference this elite group? Was it due to our fascination with Saturn and its rings? Regardless, Saturnian mythology has existed long before all of this.
Saturn comes back around to show you everything
Let's you choose what you will and will not see and then
Drags you down like a stone or lifts you up again
Spits you out like a child, light and innocent
Saturn comes back around
Lifts you up like a child
or drags you down like a stone
To consume you till you choose to let this go
Choose to let this go
The rhythmic riffing and bass-guitar-drum interweaving eventually gives way to possibly one of the top 5 heavy metal screams, coming from our little West Point graduate, Maynard. It's stupefying to behold, and one must hope he doesn't have a cough in the middle, because damn, it is long and full of wrath as he scorches the track with what has become one of his most ferocious moments as a vocalist. The only other performances that I think stand up to this are possibly Ticks & Leeches or Rosetta Stoned off of 10,000 Days. What an opener The Grudge is. It hits so hard that they need something to follow that softens the blow, which is where Eon Blue Apocalypse comes in.
4K HD scans of Alex Grey's Lateralus layers, courtesy of Redditor u/OfficialRichGuyPlays
Eon Blue Apocalypse
TOOL during Lateralus promo
The Patient
The Patient wastes no time after Eon Blue, and its rhythmic plucking tells listeners that every note, beat, and rest is deliberate, and no space is left without intent. It's a meditative riff that slowly travels as yet more guitar effects wah and respond to it. The guitars really are talking in this moment. The Patient is the first song on Lateralus that shows Maynard's more vulnerable and delicate style of singing for TOOL, as well as the group's overall cohesion when playing a softer, steady movement that keeps their music from becoming a fatiguing heavy double bass drum, guitar, and metal vocal screams in listeners' ears.
It's a dual meaning, The Patient, meaning a medical patient but also a reference to those who wait with faithful hearts. Theories suggest that it is a deeply personal take from Maynard about his mother, Judith Marie Keenan, who suffered a massive stroke in 1976 and was paralyzed and wheelchair bound for... 10,000 days (their 2006 follow-up album), give or take, until she sadly passed away in 2003 at the young age of 58. It goes without saying that Maynard is incredibly affected by this experience and his mother's unwavering faith. Judith, off of Maynard's other band, A Perfect Circle's album Mer De Noms, is specifically about faith and Jesus' suffering and sacrifice for all of us sinners. Wings for Marie parts 1 and 10,000 Days (part 2) off of that album is about her ascension. This song then, takes a deep stab at the heartstrings and twists it in.
But I'm still right here, giving blood, keeping faith
And I'm still right here
But I'm still right here, giving blood, keeping faith
And I'm still right here
Wait it out
Gonna wait it out
Wait it out (be patient)
Absolutely gut-wrenching. The sudden transition into massive soaring guitar chords and the breakaway guitar solo as Maynard laments "Gonna wait it out" is just epic, and shows their mastery at weaving a very personal life story into a heavy progressive metal song. This section of the track always feels like such a statement to me, and it sounds as if it could have been put at the end of the album due to its melodic transitions and its deep compassion. Without a doubt, there's something very different and special with TOOL than their brooding album art lets on.
Mantra
In keeping with tradition of including atmospheric and ambiguous interludes (think Useful Idiot from Ænima), Mantra is a thematic and strange detour. It sounds like a weird throwaway track of Gregorian chanting, but its substance and its title are put to good use. The feeling is that it evokes something ancient. And that's before you realize it's Maynard's cat that he's petting with its purring slowed down. ...What? I guess it is a great troll move to include the purring cat as the key to unlocking ancient wisdom. For such a serious sounding band and such a wicked sounding album, MJK does find ways to f- with his fans, or he's just smug and amusing himself with his oddball sense of humor. This isn't the first and certainly wasn't the last. Overall though, this track, Mantra, is something that is strangely fitting and even satisfying to hear, maybe for the fact that car purrs are scientifically proven to lower stress hormones. It's mysterious and dark and it fits the bill. Before too long, the album approaches its first single, an epic and an homage to interpersonal relationships.
TOOL’s Adam Jones during Lateralus
Schism
This song starts off with one of the defining moments of bass fretting. Justin's short melodic lullaby gives way to... really, such a damn cool bass riff, as his fingers seem to trill like water over the fretboard, thus creating one of TOOL's many iconic and unforgettable riffs. He is joined by Danny's tuned percussion and Adam's stormy guitar swells, as Maynard confesses on the mic,
I know the pieces fit
'Cause I watched them fall away
Mildewed and smoldering
Fundamental differing
Pure intention juxtaposed
Will set two lovers' souls in motion
Disintegrating as it goes
Testing our communication
This is the heart of the song. It is a highly unusual presentation of song, style, lyrics, and delivery that make Schism stand out and tower above most other progressive metal cuts. It's probably why TOOL won a Grammy for Best Metal Performance, because this song for some reason just sounds like it's operating on a higher level than most of the other tracks on Lateralus. I know when I first heard it, I thought it was such an insane opening, and the lyrics about broken relationships and the importance of communication, I found so mature and relatable and that it was a chilling universal message to take from it. Communication can be such a broken system. Just ask any family. This song however is for the lovers who have allowed the passage of time and consequence to pull at the sinews and fray their connection to one another. Finding a way back can sometimes seem like an impossible task. Maynard really sums it up perfectly.
The light that fueled our fire then
Has burned a hole between us so
We cannot seem to reach an end
Crippling our communication
I know the pieces fit
'Cause I watched them tumble down
No fault, none to blame
It doesn't mean I don't desire
To point the finger, blame the other
Watch the temple topple over
To bring the pieces back together
Rediscover communication
The guitar and bass riffs that swell after these lines feel so overwhelming. To relate to these lyrics while being swept up by the music I find to be one of the most cathartic experiences of heavy metal for me, probably only second to Aerials by System Of A Down, which coincidentally Toxicity also has a 25th anniversary this year (don't get me started).
There was a time that the pieces fit
But I watched them fall away
Mildewed and smoldering
Strangled by our coveting
I've done the math enough to know
The dangers of our second guessing
Doomed to crumble, unless we grow
And strengthen our communication
The breakdown and guitar echoes in this later section are really Floydian by design. They call one another and wail into the abyss. It’s madness, and this ode to communication, and feeling like we’re islands apart, is just such a universal feeling, and TOOL are the guys to highlight such a unique perspective in a heavy metal song.
Parabol
Starting off Lateralus' only two-parter is Parabol, which is a nice play on the words parable. Also, it seems fitting given TOOL's propensity for obscure, dark, mysterious art direction, that Adam would create an epic music video that's essentially a short film. This shortie is the first music video that is representative of the album, and it is done in a super compelling, practical effects, Pan Labyrinth-style grotesque dark fantasy world. It opens with some really weird business suit abominations. These Mitch McConnel-looking ghouls meet from across a stone altar, have candles for fingers, and have a bad case of black bile that oozes out of their mouth orifices. Does it fit the lyrics? Who's to say. Not really, but I'll be damned if TOOL didn't have something borderline repulsive but so compelling that you can't look away for their music videos.
Maynard helps to lay the lyrical foundation of the song, which carries over to Parabola, while Adam and Justin repeat deliciously moody, subdued riffs and Danny creates a world-style meditative call and response of cymbals that carefully and intermittently rise and embellish the track.
So familiar and overwhelmingly warm
This one, this form I hold now
Embracing you, this reality here
This one, this form I hold now, so
Wide eyed and hopeful
Wide eyed and hopefully wild
We barely remember what came before this precious moment
Choosing to be here right now
Hold on, stay inside
This body, holding me
Reminding me that I am not alone in
This body, makes me feel eternal
All this pain is an illusion
That's it for the lyrics, but they are the main focus of the entire Parabol(a) movement. They are very existential, with the thought of not knowing what has come before but the ultimate decision of the spirit to be here in the now. After the McConnel ghouls finish their horrific black vomiting, the video zooms in through a sacred geometric pattern and the epic saga expands into Parabola.
Parabola
Being the second follow-up song after Eon Blue Apocalypse -> The Patient, Parabola can be argued is the second most important song on the album, second only to the title track for obvious reasons. It is TOOL's "standard" progressive rock song of the album, and I mean that with no disrespect. If anyone who is a fan of progressive rock were to be shown a single song off this album, Parabol(a) would be the one (two). When I say it is standard, I mean it is just a solid rock song and technically flawless. I could make comparisons to other songs and artists but that would just make the TOOL army mad. Does this by-the-numbers execution make Parabol(a) wow-worthy? If I'm slightly downplaying its importance, how could I call this album a masterpiece? While I have heard this song over and over and over, I still enjoy it a great deal. And anyone new to TOOL will get the most out of it, but I am usually listening to it at this point for completion's sake and as a means to an end to get to the next more visceral track of the album. This single (double) is an essential piece of the whole, and Lateralus would be much less of an album, and possibly not really a masterpiece without it.
In this holy reality
In this holy experience
Choosing to be here in
This body, this body holding me
Be my reminder here that I am not alone in
This body, this body holding me
Feeling eternal, all this pain is an illusion
Twirling 'round with this familiar parable
Spinning, weaving 'round each new experience
Recognize this as a holy gift and
Celebrate this chance to be alive and breathing
A chance to be alive and breathing
This song has that heady and existential transcendental elements that are inseparable from TOOL lore. It makes us fans feel super intellectual and superior to others and why we are treated as insufferable… you know. It’s just a super solid track and technically flawless. It’s a primer for the even more ferocious song that follows.
Ticks & Leeches
This song is the first one that sounds like a feral beast, except it is still calculated and mathematical. Ticks & Leeches gives listeners an idea of how TOOL might sound if they were a black metal band. The opening drum solo is a marathon around Danny's drumkit, which he uses to its full potential, while Justin's bass adds some tension. After a few cycles of racing drums and steady bass, Adam's guitars howl above the mix, creating a chaotic but measured wall of sound. The singular riff that gets played alone opens the door for Maynard's unbridled growl.
Suck and suck!
Sucking up all you can
Sucking up all you can suck and suck
Working up under my patience like a little tick
Fat little parasite (parasite)
Suck me dry
My fruit is bruised and borrowed
You thieving bastards
You have turned my blood cold and bitter
Beat my compassion black and blue
Hope this is what you wanted
Hope this is what you had in mind
'Cause this is what you're getting
I hope you're choking
I hope you choke on this
I hope you're choking
I hope you choke on this
The blasting in your eardrums never felt so good as Maynard’s tourettes burst inside your earholes with a speedy staccato-like singing style. Suck it!!! Suck!! The toxic subjects and energy vampires that leech off of relationships can bring you to your knees. They are truly the vile scum you want to wipe off your shoe and Maynard’s rejection of them and hoping they choke is palpable.
The song does break though, and it feels like an aftermath of destruction. Adam and Justin’s strings are left strumming through the ashes of ground zero. The ambiance for some reason makes me think of the barking dogs breakdown of Pink Floyd’s Dogs or even many Godspeed You! Black Emperor tracks with its eerily similar crying out in the distance sound effects and their guitars that sound like violins.
Before too long though, there is something buried even further in the void, and if you listen closely you’ll be able to hear vocals. He creeps me the hell out, but if that was what they intended, it’s working. The drums start to cautiously enter the field of sound again before Ticks & Leeches grows into another killer heavy metal assault. Maynard puts all he’s got into the final chorus line, “I hope you choke!!”
TOOL - Lateralus original CD sleeve









